Andy Molitor
3 hours ago
Underdog best ball golf points don’t line up neatly with strokes gained. Under the 2027 Scramble scoring, a birdie is worth 3 points and a bogey costs half a point. Do the math on a single stroke and a birdie pays two and a half times what you get for dodging a bogey. We ran every PGA Tour start from 2023 to 2026 through those values, and three things jumped out: which weeks pay, who scores the most per start, and which golfers the scoring quietly helps or hurts.
Start with the weeks, because the spread is huge. An average golfer scores about 61 points in a start at the AT&T Pro-Am at Pebble Beach Golf Links. At the U.S. Open he scores about 24.
Most of the Signature events sit on top, since their small fields mean nearly everyone plays four rounds, along with The American Express and its birdie-fest courses. The majors sit at the bottom. Here is what an average golfer scored per start at each of the 25 Scramble events over the last three editions of each one.
| Event | Underdog round | Type | Points per start, average golfer |
|---|---|---|---|
| AT&T Pebble Beach Pro-Am | 1 | Signature | 61.0 |
| Travelers Championship | 4 | Signature | 60.8 |
| RBC Heritage | 2 | Signature | 60.8 |
| The American Express | 1 | Full field | 60.0 |
| Cadillac Championship | 2 | Signature | 58.9 |
| Truist Championship | 3 | Signature | 57.2 |
| The Genesis Invitational | 1 | Signature | 50.8 |
| THE CJ CUP Byron Nelson | 3 | Full field | 50.3 |
| John Deere Classic | 4 | Full field | 49.9 |
| Arnold Palmer Invitational | 2 | Signature | 47.3 |
| Cognizant Classic | 1 | Full field | 46.9 |
| WM Phoenix Open | 1 | Full field | 46.8 |
| RBC Canadian Open | 4 | Full field | 44.3 |
| The Players Championship | 2 | The Players | 43.4 |
| Texas Children’s Houston Open | 2 | Full field | 42.7 |
| Genesis Scottish Open | 4 | Full field | 42.4 |
| The Memorial Tournament | 3 | Signature | 42.2 |
| The Sentry | 1 | Full field | 41.9 |
| Valero Texas Open | 2 | Full field | 41.4 |
| Charles Schwab Challenge | 3 | Full field | 39.2 |
| Valspar Championship | 3 | Full field | 38.8 |
| Masters | 2 | Major | 38.4 |
| PGA Championship | 3 | Major | 37.0 |
| The Open | 4 | Major | 33.0 |
| U.S. Open | 4 | Major | 24.1 |
“Average golfer” means one who is exactly average for the PGA Tour, playing that event’s usual field and course setup. Missed cuts are baked in, which is why the full-field events sit lower than most Signature weeks. The Sentry number comes from the old Farmers fields at the same course, and the majors use their last three editions, which were played at other courses, so treat those four as a rough guide.

Two things matter for your roster. Round 1 is the richest round, at about 51 points a week for an average golfer, and Round 4 is the leanest, at about 42, because both the U.S. Open and The Open land there. And a golfer who skips the Travelers costs you more than one who skips the U.S. Open. An empty slot scores zero either way, but one of those weeks was worth more than twice as much.
These are the top 10 by projected points in a typical start, among golfers with at least 20 starts of data since 2023. Ceiling is his best week in five at a typical event, the kind of spike that wins a best ball group.
| Golfer | Points per start | Ceiling |
|---|---|---|
| Scottie Scheffler | 77.0 | 94 |
| Rory McIlroy | 68.8 | 92 |
| Tommy Fleetwood | 66.1 | 87 |
| Tyrrell Hatton | 64.7 | 92 |
| Xander Schauffele | 64.0 | 86 |
| Collin Morikawa | 63.0 | 79 |
| Hideki Matsuyama | 62.9 | 78 |
| Jon Rahm | 62.8 | 90 |
| Si Woo Kim | 62.7 | 79 |
| Matt Fitzpatrick | 62.3 | 79 |
Scheffler is eight points a start clear of everyone. That’s why he goes first in every draft, and nobody should overthink it.
The ceiling column is where it gets interesting. McIlroy, Hatton, and Rahm all have best-in-five weeks around 90, close to Scheffler’s, even though they trail him by eight to 14 points on an average start. They win weeks. Morikawa, Matsuyama, and Si Woo Kim sit in the same range on average but top out in the high 70s. They’re steadier and less likely to steal a week on their own. Hatton and Rahm don’t hold PGA Tour cards for 2027, so in the Scramble you mostly get them in the majors. In a majors-only draft, that ceiling is exactly what you want.

Since a birdie is worth so much more than a dodged bogey, golfers who gain their strokes by making birdies and living with the mess score better here than strokes gained says they should. Golfers who gain theirs by avoiding mistakes score worse. We compared each regular’s Underdog points rank with his strokes gained rank, among the 181 golfers with at least 40 starts since 2023 who played in 2026.
Underdog scoring likes Hideki Matsuyama more than strokes gained does. He’s 15th among those regulars by strokes gained and sixth in Underdog points, and he made 4.09 birdies or better per round over the last two seasons, against a tour average of 3.78. Sahith Theegala jumps from 124th by strokes gained to 50th in points. Corey Conners goes from 46th to 13th, Adam Scott from 44th to 22nd, Ryan Fox from 72nd to 36th, and Sungjae Im from 67th to 44th.
J.J. Spaun is the big name going the other way. He’s 14th by strokes gained but 34th in Underdog points. He keeps bogeys off his card better than most, with 12 percent of his rounds bogey-free against a tour average of about 10.5 percent, and Underdog only pays 3 points for a clean card. Max McGreevy drops from 69th to 127th, with 16 percent of his rounds bogey-free. Brandt Snedeker slides from 94th to 120th.
Don’t overdo it. Strokes gained is still the biggest driver of points, and style moves most golfers by only a few points a start. But when two golfers look even on your draft board, take the one who makes more birdies.
Points per start times expected starts is the number that actually decides a Scramble season. Our members board puts both together for every golfer, as season points for the Scramble and majors points for the Albatross. If you’d rather build that kind of model your own way, the Rabbit Hole lets you weight birdie rate, bogey avoidance, and strokes gained however you like. And if you play Underdog’s pick’em lines during the season too, here’s how golf pick’em props work.

We scored every PGA Tour start from 2023 to 2026 with Underdog’s 2027 values, using the birdies, pars, and bogeys in each round. Our round data doesn’t record the order of the holes, so the two streak bonuses, consecutive birdies and consecutive bogeys, are estimated from how many of each a golfer made. Each week is split into what the event was worth and what the golfer added, so a week at a birdie-fest doesn’t flatter anyone. When we tested it blind on 2026, it lined up with what golfers actually scored a little better than strokes gained alone, a correlation of 0.62 against 0.60. That’s a small edge, and we’d rather tell you that than oversell it. For the full scoring table and prize payouts, see our Underdog Scramble 2027 guide.
Get every Betsperts Golf tool, report, and Discord for free. New players who deposit at ReBet with code BSG unlock a free subscription plus a 100 percent match up to 100 dollars on a first purchase of 10 dollars.
Par is worth 0.5 points, a birdie 3, an eagle 8, a bogey minus 0.5, and a double bogey or worse minus 1. A bogey-free round adds 3, consecutive birdies add 1, and consecutive bogeys cost 1. Finishing first adds 20, sliding down to 2 points for 21st to 25th.
Scottie Scheffler, at about 77 points in a typical start. Rory McIlroy is next at about 69, then Tommy Fleetwood, Tyrrell Hatton, and Xander Schauffele, all in the mid 60s.
The AT&T Pebble Beach Pro-Am, the Travelers, and the RBC Heritage, at about 61 points for an average golfer. The U.S. Open is the lowest at about 24.
21+. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. Responsible Gaming Resources